For local pickup, these specific shops have earned strong reputations for their pumpkin offerings:
Available on Goldbelly for around (includes shipping). Their pies are known for a signature flaky crust and generational recipes. Michele's Pies $10–20Pie shop ClosedNorwalk, CT where to buy pumpkin pie
Famous for their , which has won multiple National Pie Championship awards. It is available for nationwide shipping through Goldbelly for approximately $69.95 . Sweetie Pies Bakery ClosedNapa, CA For local pickup, these specific shops have earned
: Pittsburgh Pie Guy makes pies from scratch using fresh ingredients, available at local farmers' markets and for online pickup. It is available for nationwide shipping through Goldbelly
: Costs approximately $5.99 for a massive 58-ounce (3.5 lb) pie.
: Often cited as a high-quality runner-up for those seeking specific dietary profiles.
: Consistently ranked as the top choice in taste tests by Southern Living and Serious Eats .